This or That: Gas vs. Electric Water Heaters

Related Articles

Homeowners tend to overlook one of the most energy draining products in their home, the water heater.

Twelve percent of every dollar spent on your energy bill goes directly to heating water. Recent updates to the design of many water heaters have made them exceptionally energy efficient. The average water heater has roughly a 13-year lifespan, so purchasing a water heater can be quite a commitment. The two types of water heaters available on the market are gas and electric, each offering unique benefits. How do you know which one is right for you?

Gas
Gas water heaters take about a third of what it costs to heat the same amount of water with an electric water heater, so you’ll see substantial savings in operating costs with gas. Gas water heaters do, however, require a larger upfront investment as well as a natural gas outlet that some homes need to have installed. Gas water heaters also need extra safety precautions — they need to be vented outside as well as have regular seal maintenance on the combustion and power venting to increase safety. After the initial investment, however, gas water heaters are more economically and environmentally responsible in the long term.

Electric
Electric water heaters typically cost less upfront than gas water heaters. They are easy to maintain and require no venting or combustibles. However, electric water heaters take longer to heat the same amount of water than gas water heaters. Because they use electricity, electric water heaters can have significant impacts on your electricity bill if not properly maintained or insulated. If you choose an electric water heater, you may want to consider utilizing a solar hot water system to help save on electricity. Find out more about solar hot water systems.

No matter which model you choose, your water heater will be one of the largest consumers of energy in your home. You may opt for tankless or on-demand water heaters that heat water only as it’s being used. These water heaters can save you between 10-20% on water heating costs and come in both electric and gas models.

What are your experiences with gas and electric water heaters? Have you found one to be better than the other? Leave your answers in the comments.

11 comments
Trade Certificates
Trade Certificates

This is a good question being an electrician I would probably always go with electrical water heaters as I can test them quite easily and repair them quite easily but my partner is a gas engineer who also does this who I am sure would go with gas so I guess it actually comes down to preference


http://tradecertificates.co.uk

KentClark1
KentClark1

I think it really just depends on who you are. Electric water heaters do seem like they would be cheaper and more compatible with solar homes, but that isn't necessarily what everyone is looking for. However, you did say in the article that gas heaters are more economical in the long run. Perhaps that validates the reason for buying one a little bit more. http://www.abelplumbinginc.com/Water_Heaters.html 

geraldvonberger
geraldvonberger

This is an interesting comparison. I guess the decision between gas and electric water heaters comes down to what maintenance costs you want to deal with. It sounds like electric is a good option as long as you keep it well-maintained and insulated. http://www.andersonwater.com/hot-water-tanks

JaxWillis23
JaxWillis23

The biggest thing to remember is to do things in a way that you'll get the best option possible to help you. I know that I would struggle a bit if I didn't have the best option available. Talking to a professional is probably the best way to get the information you need. I would suggest trying to find that help if possible.

http://www.clearwaterplumbing.com/tankless-water-heaters/ 

avalaurie86
avalaurie86

I would take that investment and get the gas heating. I think it will essentially pay for itself over time with all the savings you'll get. Now that i think of it, I don't think I have ever lived in house that didn't have gas heating.  http://www.statewidemechanicalinc.net

James Lisbon
James Lisbon

Who knew that 12% of every dollar spent on energy went towards heating water?  It would probably depend on personal circumstances as to which kind of water heater someone would get.   However, it is probably a good thing that there are options to choose from. http://www.rapidplumbinglex.com/water-heaters 

bryanflake1984
bryanflake1984

There are definitely things to consider when choosing a water heater system.  I had no idea that gas systems take a third of what the other water heaters take to heat essentially the same amount of water.  For me the debate is upfront cost vs. lifespan of the system.  It is a constant back and forth of what do I really want more?

http://www.mcdermottplumbing.com/water-heater-installations.html

James Lisbon
James Lisbon

It is interesting to read the differences between electric and gas heaters.  I didn't know that gas heaters could heat water a little more efficiently than electric heaters.  Putting a water heater in a home is probably something that requires a little bit of research so that you can make an informed decision you your circumstances. http://www.mcdermottplumbing.com/water-heater-installations.html 

AshleyReed
AshleyReed

I wonder what kind of water heater we have, is there a way to tell? I'm thinking about switching out my water heater, it doesn't do its job very well. It's probably as old as this house is. I'm not even really sure where the water heater is, I've probably seen it before and didn't even know what I was looking at. http://gasmasterstampa.com/water_heaters.htm 

brookexzcason
brookexzcason

I had no idea 12 percent of an energy bill could be related to the cost of heating water. Should consumers purchase of a hot water heater take into consideration the region or climate in which they live? Thank you for sharing this article; it is very informative. http://www.plumbperfect.ca/brampton-plumbing'

JuliaAllan
JuliaAllan

Thanks for the article, it is very instructive. I found this website if you would like to read further information: www.archiexpo.com/architecture-design-manufacturer/electric-water-heater-1584.html